|
Post by bronco on Feb 21, 2024 17:27:53 GMT -5
It is official, per today's flowrestling podcast, virginia is the easiest and i quote "preposterous!'' if you dont have a flo account you can find replay on youtube 'where is it toughest to win state title in wrestling' @2:00 min. mark. that should stir the pot a little....
|
|
|
Post by cavfan on Feb 21, 2024 19:26:00 GMT -5
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.nfhs.org/media/5989280/2021-22_participation_survey.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwj_qdeh0r2EAxWMD1kFHVmZCz0QFnoECBsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1Sz2C8Jq94CJOnqGS2XBOHHere is a link to participation numbers by school/ athletes, by sport. Everyone can agree on New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and California being competitive. The all have roughly 9000 or more high school wrestlers and smaller number of classes. Iowa has 288 schools with Wrestling and 5900 wrestlers. Virginia has 271 schools with Wrestling and 5600 wrestlers. Iowa has 3 classes, Virginia 6 (I believe the report only includes public school numbers) Virginia population: 8.6 million Iowa population: 3.1 million Virginia has 2 1/2 times the population but less wrestlers. Maybe it is a culture/participation issue. Even the smallest classes in states like Iowa fill a full roster with backups. If Virginia could do that 6 classes wouldn't matter as much. For the record I still think we should have 3. Instead of complaining on what VHSL does, we should focus on building up Wrestling. Especially those 1a and 2a schools. If we could get 10,000 wrestlers like some states of similar population VA wrestling would be very competitive!
|
|
|
Post by wagner911 on Feb 21, 2024 21:31:36 GMT -5
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.nfhs.org/media/5989280/2021-22_participation_survey.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwj_qdeh0r2EAxWMD1kFHVmZCz0QFnoECBsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1Sz2C8Jq94CJOnqGS2XBOHHere is a link to participation numbers by school/ athletes, by sport. Everyone can agree on New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and California being competitive. The all have roughly 9000 or more high school wrestlers and smaller number of classes. Iowa has 288 schools with Wrestling and 5900 wrestlers. Virginia has 271 schools with Wrestling and 5600 wrestlers. Iowa has 3 classes, Virginia 6 (I believe the report only includes public school numbers) Virginia population: 8.6 million Iowa population: 3.1 million Virginia has 2 1/2 times the population but less wrestlers. Maybe it is a culture/participation issue. Even the smallest classes in states like Iowa fill a full roster with backups. If Virginia could do that 6 classes wouldn't matter as much. For the record I still think we should have 3. Instead of complaining on what VHSL does, we should focus on building up Wrestling. Especially those 1a and 2a schools. If we could get 10,000 wrestlers like some states of similar population VA wrestling would be very competitive! Flo and Askren are rarely right on anything. Keep that in mind. That said, Spreading out the talent weakens the competition. Competition is what breeds excitement. Excitement is what builds the numbers of wrestlers. Moral of the story is get rid of the trophy crowd, cut divisions in half…. Watch the numbers grow. Almost everyone agrees with this. Not sure who the gatekeepers are preventing common sense to prevail
|
|
|
Post by bronco on Feb 21, 2024 22:35:23 GMT -5
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.nfhs.org/media/5989280/2021-22_participation_survey.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwj_qdeh0r2EAxWMD1kFHVmZCz0QFnoECBsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1Sz2C8Jq94CJOnqGS2XBOHHere is a link to participation numbers by school/ athletes, by sport. Everyone can agree on New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and California being competitive. The all have roughly 9000 or more high school wrestlers and smaller number of classes. Iowa has 288 schools with Wrestling and 5900 wrestlers. Virginia has 271 schools with Wrestling and 5600 wrestlers. Iowa has 3 classes, Virginia 6 (I believe the report only includes public school numbers) Virginia population: 8.6 million Iowa population: 3.1 million Virginia has 2 1/2 times the population but less wrestlers. Maybe it is a culture/participation issue. Even the smallest classes in states like Iowa fill a full roster with backups. If Virginia could do that 6 classes wouldn't matter as much. For the record I still think we should have 3. Instead of complaining on what VHSL does, we should focus on building up Wrestling. Especially those 1a and 2a schools. If we could get 10,000 wrestlers like some states of similar population VA wrestling would be very competitive! wash., ariz, mass, indiana debunk your theory im thinking. youve never wrestled so its hard to explain how significant an accomplishment a state Wrestling medal of any color is or rather used to be. the sport in and of itself is arguably the purest sport. correct me if im wrong but there isnt a headgear to make you more aerodynamic, a singlet that reduces drag during a double leg or even shoes,etc. opposed to tennis racket baseball glove football pads, whew i hope you get the point. its just you and your opponent(okay ill bite, kinesiology tape lol). we have tshirts remarking how "once youve wrestled everything else is easy' and boys play bb, men wrestle etc etc etc. point is that its not about the wrestlers we dont have(ie. Ca., wv, del) its about the wrestlers we do have. All want a medal along with the Respect that comes with it. i can expand for hours but take my word its deep with us. we talk about it when we are 60 like it was yesterday. its painful watching powerhouse grundy having to justify their wins like a stuart smally skit from snl( no slight grundy folks, love and respect the program), but they arent getting the respect they deserve when you put 10-12 in finals at a state championship. 300+ points in a state championship does anyone really believe btwn strasburg, poquoson etc. arguably 2a may or may not wipe out half those points alone?! if you do good for you i just cant buy it. records are one of the most important parts of sports. they link generations of fans and athletes together, and are a way for us to compare players from completely different eras. its not to poke holes for comedic relief or adorn asterisks. four timer garnered the utmost respect regrettably now everyone is a 3x and 4x'er it's ridiculous. last thought, i dont see how population vs participation makes a tourny more or less competitive. iowa has 5000+ wrestlers so does va. sounds like when i go deep sea fishing sure its great to get 70 dolphin in an hour and head home. but its catching that marlin and putting it above the mantle everyone talks about the most. its not that i agree with the shows comments some times but the fact we were made a joke in front of our peers nationally is cause for alarm. i dont know if half what i wrote makes sense or if im right at all but i can say this, until youve won one you.....iykyk
|
|
|
Post by wrestlingfan2244 on Feb 21, 2024 22:37:21 GMT -5
It’s a battle I don’t think we can win. I just think if you’re a Va wrestler you have to wrestle out of state. As more kids go to the Beast , iron man, and Powerade to name a few. It will have an impact on the money revenue for VHSL. and that’s when it will change. Va is moving forward but it’s slow. It’s the great coaches, clubs and parents that are making the difference for our va state wrestlers.
|
|
|
Post by matman on Feb 21, 2024 22:40:17 GMT -5
Maybe as we get known for being an easy state to win a title or get a medal in it will attract more mediocre wrestlers and boost our numbers
|
|
|
Post by cavfan on Feb 22, 2024 7:08:35 GMT -5
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.nfhs.org/media/5989280/2021-22_participation_survey.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwj_qdeh0r2EAxWMD1kFHVmZCz0QFnoECBsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1Sz2C8Jq94CJOnqGS2XBOHHere is a link to participation numbers by school/ athletes, by sport. Everyone can agree on New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and California being competitive. The all have roughly 9000 or more high school wrestlers and smaller number of classes. Iowa has 288 schools with Wrestling and 5900 wrestlers. Virginia has 271 schools with Wrestling and 5600 wrestlers. Iowa has 3 classes, Virginia 6 (I believe the report only includes public school numbers) Virginia population: 8.6 million Iowa population: 3.1 million Virginia has 2 1/2 times the population but less wrestlers. Maybe it is a culture/participation issue. Even the smallest classes in states like Iowa fill a full roster with backups. If Virginia could do that 6 classes wouldn't matter as much. For the record I still think we should have 3. Instead of complaining on what VHSL does, we should focus on building up Wrestling. Especially those 1a and 2a schools. If we could get 10,000 wrestlers like some states of similar population VA wrestling would be very competitive! wash., ariz, mass, indiana debunk your theory im thinking. youve never wrestled so its hard to explain how significant an accomplishment a state Wrestling medal of any color is or rather used to be. the sport in and of itself is arguably the purest sport. correct me if im wrong but there isnt a headgear to make you more aerodynamic, a singlet that reduces drag during a double leg or even shoes,etc. opposed to tennis racket baseball glove football pads, whew i hope you get the point. its just you and your opponent(okay ill bite, kinesiology tape lol). we have tshirts remarking how "once youve wrestled everything else is easy' and boys play bb, men wrestle etc etc etc. point is that its not about the wrestlers we dont have(ie. Ca., wv, del) its about the wrestlers we do have. All want a medal along with the Respect that comes with it. i can expand for hours but take my word its deep with us. we talk about it when we are 60 like it was yesterday. its painful watching powerhouse grundy having to justify their wins like a stuart smally skit from snl( no slight grundy folks, love and respect the program), but they arent getting the respect they deserve when you put 10-12 in finals at a state championship. 300+ points in a state championship does anyone really believe btwn strasburg, poquoson etc. arguably 2a may or may not wipe out half those points alone?! if you do good for you i just cant buy it. records are one of the most important parts of sports. they link generations of fans and athletes together, and are a way for us to compare players from completely different eras. its not to poke holes for comedic relief or adorn asterisks. four timer garnered the utmost respect regrettably now everyone is a 3x and 4x'er it's ridiculous. last thought, i dont see how population vs participation makes a tourny more or less competitive. iowa has 5000+ wrestlers so does va. sounds like when i go deep sea fishing sure its great to get 70 dolphin in an hour and head home. but its catching that marlin and putting it above the mantle everyone talks about the most. its not that i agree with the shows comments some times but the fact we were made a joke in front of our peers nationally is cause for alarm. i dont know if half what i wrote makes sense or if im right at all but i can say this, until youve won one you.....iykyk Maybe I'm wrong. It is just a theory. But I grew up wrestling for a small 1A high school in Iowa and later at an NAIA college. From experience I can tell you that we never saw a 4-5 man team. Most of the teams from one stop light towns would still mix it up with big city teams. We had about 300 students in our school but had a full roster and a nearly full JV. The percentage of student population that wrestled was higher. The schedule tougher. I think we averaged 9 tournaments per year. I draw from those experiences. I am a Virginia wrestling dad now and want to see the sport grow. Hearing VA wrestling get laughed at on Flo hurt. Going to 3 classes will make the state medal harder to earn. I fully support 3 classes. But that won't necessarily fix the caliber of wrestling throughout the season at dual meets. I couldn't believe how many pins I saw at my first VA HS dual. Iron sharpens iron and until we can field full rosters going to 3 classes won't help the struggling teams. My point of the last post was: Unless you have some influence on the VHSL, we should focus as much as we can on improving the sport. I believe VA wrestling is growing and that's great. Fundraisers, boosters, find ways to increase attendance and community support as well.
|
|
|
Post by warriorswrestling on Feb 22, 2024 7:57:01 GMT -5
The issue is the growth at the lower levels. Someone on a different thread mentioned starting up RTCs. Not a terrible idea. But so many of the smaller schools have no youth development. Very few small schools have middle school teams. Most schools are getting kids in high school and are trying to survive. Smaller schools in poor areas struggle with funding and the community struggles to support them for multiple reasons.
How to fix that, I am not sure. You have to get several passionate people together in an area to do so, and a facility and money to grow. I helped get a local club started and it took the coach 3 years to find an OK facility at a decent price. Thankfully one I didn't have to run this because I was burning myself out. I dropped by the other night and they had 25 kids in there. For an area like this? That's awesome.
But if you truly want to grow the sport, it starts at the bottom.
|
|
|
Post by swvawatcher on Feb 22, 2024 10:28:04 GMT -5
HS wrestling is being hurt by travel sports and specialized sports teams for the entire year starting so young.
Most kids are not exposed to a chance to wrestle until they are in 7th grade around me. By then a lot of the good athletes are specialized already. How to combat that I don't know but I see signs for tee ball sign up every day, and if I was not already a wrestling parent I don't know I'd ever even consider it.
When I was in HS wrestling was pushed as winter sport for football/baseball/track guys hard. Now not so much that I hear as they are more worried about year round training and work.
|
|
|
Post by chrisrowe on Feb 22, 2024 11:27:11 GMT -5
Even after reading many well-written pro-3 class system posts, I still struggle to see how that will really improve quality of wrestling in VA. Sure, for entertainment value we will get more high caliber matches at States but the benefits won't extend far beyond that.
After States, kids have plenty of opportunities to test themselves at higher level - NHSCA, Fargo, Super 32, Beast, etc. so the lack of competition is not the issue. In my opinion, the lack of regular access to high level coaching and practice with high level peers is the reason. Many schools have 1-2 hammers, those hammers won't be able to compete at national level unless they are given regular access to high level coaching and partners in practice.
So yes, for me, I see setting up regional RTCs and having coaches (even college ones) train and live wrestling is the way to improve. Once a week, 3 hour on Sat afternoon. You need to place in top 3 at States (because we don't have true 2nd). We do this for a couple of years, you will start to see VA kids go further in national level competition. The 3rd place match at state will be exciting because the kids would want to be a part of this program.
Heck, we can even see if we can use college facilities to host RTC - George Mason, Roanoke College, UVA, VT, etc. the kids will be exposed to college coaches naturally.
|
|
|
Post by matman on Feb 22, 2024 13:06:06 GMT -5
I think more training opportunities for coaches would help. Some schools have coaches that haven't wrestled or very little experience with the sport. Nothing wrong with that just very little opportunity to develop themselves as coaches and get advice and knowledge.
|
|
|
Post by earlsmith on Feb 22, 2024 13:47:17 GMT -5
Even after reading many well-written pro-3 class system posts, I still struggle to see how that will really improve quality of wrestling in VA. Sure, for entertainment value we will get more high caliber matches at States but the benefits won't extend far beyond that. After States, kids have plenty of opportunities to test themselves at higher level - NHSCA, Fargo, Super 32, Beast, etc. so the lack of competition is not the issue. In my opinion, the lack of regular access to high level coaching and practice with high level peers is the reason. Many schools have 1-2 hammers, those hammers won't be able to compete at national level unless they are given regular access to high level coaching and partners in practice. So yes, for me, I see setting up regional RTCs and having coaches (even college ones) train and live wrestling is the way to improve. Once a week, 3 hour on Sat afternoon. You need to place in top 3 at States (because we don't have true 2nd). We do this for a couple of years, you will start to see VA kids go further in national level competition. The 3rd place match at state will be exciting because the kids would want to be a part of this program. Heck, we can even see if we can use college facilities to host RTC - George Mason, Roanoke College, UVA, VT, etc. the kids will be exposed to college coaches naturally. A few years ago, I tried to get something like this off the ground, primarily working with middle school kids. I spoke to coaches at all of those colleges you mentioned and each was willing to work with us, some using their facilities and their wrestlers/RTC guys as clinicians. In fact, Tony Robie and Sam Latona led one of our workouts. It only benefits them if the state gets better, so they want to assist with the process. I also had conversations with a handful of people involved with club wrestling in Georgia and they had a similar system of multiple clubs and their top wrestlers getting together and working out frequently. The kids involved with this Georgia wave are now currently college and had great results in high school - some have in college too. There were a couple of different factors that prevented it from really getting it going, but it's still something I believe in. I hate the 6 classes and think they should go away immediately, but improving at the grassroots level is probably more important.
|
|
|
Post by maroondude on Feb 22, 2024 13:55:46 GMT -5
Easy is relative..... Starting wrasslin after finishing football after the second Saturday in December can make it quite difficult................
|
|
|
Post by gopbbroncos on Mar 5, 2024 16:14:05 GMT -5
I wanted to give a synopsis on wrestling in Arizona real quick since we're comparing apples and oranges. There are 203 schools with 4728 participants, and there are approximately 900 girls. One of the things that makes Arizona unique from Virginia is the fact that all of the public, private, and charter schools pretty much all wrestle under the Arizona Interscholastic Association (AIA); there are some smaller schools, though, that compete in the Canyon Athletic Association (CAA). There are four divisions, and in those four divisions are four sectionals; girls have two divisions with four sections.
One thing that also makes Arizona unique is we only have a sectional tournament and a state tournament. My school (Poston Butte HS) is in Division III Section II, and the girls are in Division II Section IV. Whether or not it makes it easier or harder to win the state is up for debate. Poston won its sectional and qualified 11 for states, but we took 10th at states. My previous school, Queen Creek, happened to be in the same section as Sunnyside, which is a wrestling powerhouse (RBY went to Sunnyside).
One thing, however, is the AIA changes alignments every two years, so that changes things up and can work to your advantage or disadvantage.
I really wish Virginia would think outside the box and do what other states do, in that they have separate sections for each sport.
|
|